Entering a new, healthy relationship after experiencing a toxic one can feel like stepping into the sunlight after years in the dark. It’s warm, safe, and nurturing—but sometimes, the shadows of the past still linger. Triggers can surface unexpectedly, making it difficult to fully embrace the security and love your new relationship offers.
If you find yourself reacting to past wounds in your current relationship, know that you are not alone. Healing is a journey, and it is absolutely possible to navigate these triggers while fostering a loving and secure connection.
Understanding Triggers
Triggers are emotional responses tied to past experiences. In the context of a toxic relationship, they often stem from moments of betrayal, manipulation, gaslighting, or emotional neglect. When something in your current relationship—no matter how innocent—reminds you of those painful moments, your brain may react as if the threat is happening all over again.
Common triggers might include:
A certain tone of voice or phrase
A partner needing space or time alone
Conflict or disagreements
Unexpected changes in plans
Recognizing your triggers is the first step toward managing them. Instead of feeling ashamed or frustrated, acknowledge them as remnants of past experiences that do not define your present.
Communicate with Your Partner
A healthy relationship thrives on open and honest communication. Your partner cannot read your mind, and they may not understand why certain situations cause distress. When you feel safe, share your experiences and explain how they impact you. Use "I" statements to express your feelings, such as:
"I sometimes get anxious when plans change unexpectedly because, in my past relationship, that often meant I was being manipulated."
"When voices are raised, I feel overwhelmed because I associate that with past conflict that didn’t feel safe."
A supportive partner will want to understand your experiences and help you feel secure. They may not always get it right, but with patience and guidance, they can learn how to support you.
Practice Self-Regulation Techniques
When a trigger arises, it can feel like your emotions are taking over. Developing self-regulation strategies can help ground you in the present and remind you that you are safe. Some helpful techniques include:
Deep breathing: Try the 4-7-8 technique—inhale for four seconds, hold for seven, and exhale for eight.
Grounding exercises: Engage your senses by noticing five things you see, four things you feel, three things you hear, two things you smell, and one thing you taste.
Positive affirmations: Remind yourself, “I am safe. This is not my past relationship.”
Movement: Go for a walk, stretch, or engage in another physical activity to release tension.
Challenge Negative Thoughts
Toxic relationships can leave lasting beliefs about love and self-worth. You may catch yourself thinking, "I’m too much," "They’ll leave me," or "I can’t trust anyone." These thoughts are echoes of the past, not truths of the present. Challenge them by asking:
What evidence do I have that this thought is true?
How would I comfort a friend who had this thought?
What would a more balanced perspective look like?
Over time, replacing these thoughts with self-compassionate and rational responses can help reshape your beliefs about relationships.
Embrace the Differences in Your New Relationship
It can feel strange—almost unsettling—when a new relationship doesn’t follow the dysfunctional patterns you were once used to. You might find yourself waiting for the other shoe to drop, struggling to accept kindness, or doubting the security of your connection.
Remind yourself that a healthy relationship may feel different, but different doesn’t mean wrong. Allow yourself to embrace the stability, respect, and care your new partner offers. Healing happens in safe, supportive relationships, and it’s okay to lean into that.
Seek Professional Support
Sometimes, triggers can feel overwhelming, and navigating them alone may not be enough. Therapy—whether individual or couples-based—can provide tools and guidance to help you heal while strengthening your relationship. An experienced therapist can help you process past wounds, build self-trust, and develop strategies to manage triggers in a way that fosters emotional growth.
Final Thoughts
Healing from a toxic relationship while embracing a healthy one is a process that requires patience, self-awareness, and support. It’s okay to have moments of struggle, but don’t let the past dictate your future. You deserve love that is safe, respectful, and nurturing. With time and intentional effort, you can break free from old patterns and fully experience the joy of a relationship built on mutual trust and care.
If you’re looking for support in your healing journey, our practice is here to help. Reach out today to take the next step toward emotional freedom and fulfilling relationships.
About our EMDR Eating Disorder Therapist Stephanie Polizzi
Stephanie Polizzi is a licensed psychotherapist (LMHC) and eating disorder specialist in Scarsdale, NY at Peaceful Living Mental Health Counseling, serving clients living in NY, NJ and FL.
Stephanie specializes in working with children, teens and adults struggling with anxiety, eating disorders, behavioral challenges, life transitions and trauma.
Stephanie uses a combination of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT), Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), Mindfulness, Cognitive Processing Therapy (CPT)and EMDR Therapy in her work with clients.
Comments